Origination26 min read

How to Evaluate a Buy-Side Origination Firm

Owner interest is something to assess, and something a capable originator can help develop.

Shivam ShirolawalaFounder & Managing Partner

In this article

    Buy-side origination has become a crowded category. An investor can interview several firms and hear similar promises: thoughtful research, proprietary opportunities, senior relationships, and an extension of the investment team.

    The owners those firms approach are hearing their own versions of the same proposition. Several credible buyers would like to acquire their business. Each has capital, an investment thesis, and a reason the company fits.

    The difficult work is giving the owner a reason to care about a particular partnership.

    That requires understanding the company, representing the buyer credibly, developing a substantive conversation, and helping both parties determine whether there is something worth pursuing. An introduction is one visible result of that work. Much of the judgment that determines its quality happens before the investment team enters the conversation.

    My perspective comes from working with private-market data, helping build origination functions inside private equity, and then building a firm around the function. One distinction has become central to how I evaluate the work: owner interest is something to assess, and something a capable originator can help develop.

    An owner’s willingness to consider a transaction can change as they understand what a particular partnership might mean. That creates a meaningful difference between finding someone willing to take a meeting and developing an opportunity the buyer has a credible reason to pursue.

    To evaluate a buy-side origination firm, you need to see how it makes those judgments. Follow the work from the market map through the owner conversation, introduction, and subsequent relationship. Establish what the firm contributes at each stage and what responsibility remains with you.

    This guide focuses on direct buy-side origination: researching companies, engaging their owners, and developing acquisition opportunities for a particular buyer. Intermediary coverage and transaction execution can also form part of an engagement. Establish whether those services are included and who is responsible for them.

    Be precise about proprietary, too. A relationship developed directly for your firm does not automatically mean the owner is speaking only with you. An origination firm’s commitment to represent you exclusively within a defined mandate is separate from any exclusivity agreed with the owner. Understand the actual access and relationship being offered.

    Start with how owner interest develops

    Suppose an owner says, “I’m not looking to sell.”

    That tells you something about their current position. It may leave unanswered whether they understand the buyer, whether a particular partnership could be relevant, or whether there are circumstances under which they would consider a transaction.

    Now suppose another owner says, “Sure, I’ll hear them out.”

    That establishes willingness to have a conversation. It leaves many of the same questions unanswered.

    A pipeline can misrepresent both situations if the first owner is immediately classified as uninterested and the second is treated as a developed opportunity. The quality of the subsequent conversation matters.

    Consider a hypothetical regional commercial services company approached on behalf of a larger platform. The owner is concerned about giving up local decision-making.

    One interpretation is that the owner wants to retain control. That may be accurate, but it is incomplete.

    Through further discussion, the owner explains that customers value the company’s ability to respond quickly and make decisions locally. The concern is that centralized dispatch and additional approvals could damage the relationships that make the business attractive in the first place.

    That changes the commercial question.

    The buyer now needs to explain how the operating relationship would work. Which decisions would remain local? Where would the platform provide support? Would its model preserve the responsiveness customers value?

    If the buyer can provide a credible answer, the owner has something specific to evaluate. If the buyer’s operating model is incompatible with what the owner considers essential, that also needs to become clear.

    A generic assurance that the buyer is “founder-friendly” resolves very little.

    The originator’s contribution is recognizing what the concern means, connecting it to the actual capabilities and intentions of the buyer, and helping the parties address it. An owner who initially saw only disruption may come to see a partnership worth exploring. An apparent opportunity may also turn out to contain a fundamental mismatch.

    Both outcomes improve the buyer’s understanding.

    Interest should have an identifiable reason

    When a firm describes an owner as interested, I would want to understand what the interest is in.

    Learning about valuation? Finding a path to retirement? Exploring resources for growth? Understanding whether a buyer could help solve a leadership problem? Meeting an investor without any current transaction objective?

    Those are different starting points. None should be silently substituted for another.

    In the hypothetical example, a useful development would be the owner agreeing to meet the platform’s operating leadership to understand how the businesses could work together. The reason for the meeting is clear. So is the issue that needs to be addressed.

    That is more informative than a calendar invitation accompanied by “owner is open.”

    Persuasive origination helps an owner evaluate a real possibility. The buyer should be able to see what made that possibility relevant and what remains unresolved.

    Examine who develops the buyer’s story

    The investment thesis explains why the buyer wants the company. The owner needs to understand why engaging with that buyer could be worthwhile.

    Those explanations require different work.

    A buyer may value customer relationships, geographic coverage, recurring work, or an attractive service offering. The owner may be thinking about management responsibilities, personal liquidity, employee continuity, or the demands of another stage of growth.

    The originator needs enough understanding of both sides to connect them accurately.

    This is where storytelling becomes commercially important. A persuasive story explains what a particular partnership could make possible, how it might work, and why the buyer is credible.

    “Capital and resources” leaves most of that unexplained.

    Which resources? Who would provide them? What would the owner be able to do that is difficult today? What has the buyer accomplished in a comparable situation? Which parts of that experience could apply here?

    The person developing the positioning needs to work through those questions with the buyer. The people making calls need to understand the answers well enough to respond naturally when an owner takes the discussion somewhere unexpected.

    A polished summary of a pitch deck is insufficient preparation for a substantive conversation.

    Understand what the owner would do without a transaction

    The owner’s alternative may be another buyer. It may also be hiring a president, promoting a colleague, accepting slower growth, or continuing to operate the company as it stands.

    A transaction has to make sense relative to those choices.

    In one discussion our team helped arrange, the buyer was considering leadership support as part of an acquisition. The owner was already pursuing a president hire independently. He wanted the buyer to consider that person if a transaction happened, and explained that proceeding with the hire could pause the sale discussion. Price remained part of the negotiation.

    That detail changed the relevance of the buyer’s proposition.

    The owner already had a possible path toward addressing the leadership need. The useful questions concerned whether the buyer could incorporate that candidate, what additional capabilities it could contribute, and how the timing of the hiring decision affected the transaction discussion.

    Simply repeating that the buyer could provide management support would have missed the situation.

    This is the depth I would look for when evaluating positioning. Does the firm understand the owner’s choices well enough to explain where the buyer fits among them?

    Make the story specific enough to examine

    A buyer’s prior acquisitions can supply useful evidence, provided the originator understands what actually happened.

    If a founder stepped back after an acquisition, who absorbed the responsibilities? Was a management team already in place? What did the buyer contribute? How did the transition work?

    If the buyer offers operating support, which people are available and what can they realistically do? An executive interested in a thesis, an executive committed to joining, and an executive ready to begin immediately represent different facts.

    Each can support a credible proposition when described accurately.

    The same precision matters when an owner raises a question the buyer has not yet resolved. The originator should recognize the gap and bring it back to the appropriate person. Developing a better answer can be part of the firm’s contribution.

    Positioning should improve as the search develops. Owners will reveal which parts are relevant, which are unclear, and which require more substance.

    Be clear about who is speaking for whom

    The relationship between the originator and the buyer is part of the story.

    Will the firm present itself as a retained advisor, an external origination partner, or an outsourced member of the acquisition team? When will the buyer’s identity be introduced? How will the caller explain whom it represents and how it is paid?

    An external team can become closely integrated into an acquisition program. Its description of that relationship should remain accurate.

    The caller also needs clear boundaries around what it can represent about integration, management roles, transaction structure, and valuation. Those boundaries should allow a useful discussion while preserving the buyer’s authority over its commitments.

    If the firm serves multiple clients, understand the specific mandate behind your approach. Is the relationship being developed for you? Could the opportunity be presented elsewhere? What happens if another client becomes interested in the same company?

    The owner’s understanding of the relationship should remain coherent from the first approach through the buyer introduction.

    Research determines which companies get that opportunity

    The commercial work begins earlier than the first call.

    Research determines which companies the team will consider, whom it will approach, and what assumptions it carries into the conversation. Weak decisions at this stage can remove attractive businesses from the search before anyone has a chance to understand them.

    Start with what the market map actually counts.

    Are the records independent companies, operating subsidiaries, brands, or locations? Have acquired businesses been identified? Do several entries lead to the same owner or acquisition decision?

    Five hundred records can represent a substantially different number of actionable companies.

    Start with how the firm finds the companies it plans to approach. Which databases does it use? What does it draw from industry directories, trade associations, company websites, and other sector-specific sources? How does it investigate parts of the market where the available data is thin?

    Then understand who performs the research. Whether the work is handled internally or with an outside research partner, someone needs to translate your investment thesis into instructions the researchers can apply. Who does that? How much do the researchers understand about the businesses you want to acquire? Who reviews their judgments before the list reaches the people making calls?

    The approach to inclusion deserves particular attention. Does the team begin broadly, retaining plausible companies for further investigation, or require stronger evidence of fit before including them? What is sufficient grounds for an exclusion? Which uncertainties are passed to the caller to resolve?

    Those choices affect both coverage and the work required to qualify the market. A broader approach can preserve opportunities that are difficult to assess from public information. A narrower approach can concentrate effort where there is a stronger initial basis for fit. The firm should be able to explain why its approach makes sense for your mandate.

    Have the team walk through a few companies from the original source to the decision to pursue, investigate further, or exclude. That will show you how the research is actually performed and where judgment enters the process.

    Distinguish evidence from inference

    An industry classification may be too broad for the distinctions your thesis requires. The relevant differences can sit in customer type, service mix, delivery model, labor structure, geographic density, or revenue characteristics.

    A company described as a maintenance provider might earn most of its revenue from installations. A company whose website emphasizes projects might have a substantial service business underneath. Repeat customers and contracted recurring revenue can describe different economic relationships.

    The research process should preserve what is known, what is inferred, and what requires primary contact.

    This affects how narrowly to screen the market.

    Buyers usually see the cost of a poor inclusion. An irrelevant company reaches the investment team, someone identifies the mismatch, and the wasted effort becomes visible.

    A poor exclusion is harder to detect. The company disappears before the buyer sees it.

    A clean-looking list can therefore reflect careful research or an excessively restrictive screen. The distinction becomes clearer when you inspect excluded and unresolved companies alongside the included ones.

    In our own work, I have had to revisit how much weight we placed on the prominence of a service on a company’s website. Prominence can be a poor proxy for economic importance. A relevant capability may sit beneath a broader description, or the company may use terminology that differs from the investor’s.

    That does not make every ambiguous business attractive. It means uncertainty needs a defensible treatment.

    Know whom to approach and what to learn

    Contact research requires judgment too.

    The founder named on the website may no longer own the business. A president may manage operations while someone else controls a sale decision. Several shareholders may need to agree. The best initial contact and the ultimate decision-maker can be different people.

    The team should have a reason for its contact strategy and a way to update it as ownership and decision-making become clearer.

    Before outreach begins, I would expect a useful starting guide to the market: its principal business models, relevant terminology, distinctions that matter to the thesis, initial inclusion decisions, and questions requiring direct conversations.

    That guide should improve through contact.

    When an owner contradicts a classification, the team needs to determine whether it has learned something about one company or uncovered a flawed assumption affecting many. Correcting the record is useful. Correcting the underlying research judgment can change the search.

    Evaluate what happens inside the owner conversation

    A well-researched company and a credible buyer story create the conditions for a productive conversation. The person making the call still has to use them.

    The owner is assessing the caller while the caller learns about the business. Does this person understand what the company does? Are they listening? Can they explain why the approach is relevant? Do they respond thoughtfully when the conversation moves beyond prepared material?

    That assessment tends to run in a stable order: who are you, who pays you, what have you bought, what happened to the last owner, what happens to my people. Price usually comes last, and in many first conversations it never comes up at all.

    Owners have also told us plainly what earns the candid version of the conversation. One, who let most approaches go unanswered, explained why persistence got their attention: “If someone is persistent, I’m always interested. And what’s driving that.” Another, hearing an honest admission rather than a bluff, approved of it on the spot: “If you don’t know, it’s better.” Persistence supported by visible research reads as conviction. Candor gets answered with candor.

    Rapport matters because it can make the discussion more candid and substantive.

    A pleasant exchange may produce an agreement to reconnect without revealing much. A stronger conversation might establish why the owner has resisted previous approaches, what would make a partnership attractive, or which part of the buyer’s proposition needs further examination.

    That depth has to be earned.

    The caller needs enough preparation to ask relevant questions, enough commercial understanding to interpret the answers, and enough flexibility to adjust. A detail about customer relationships, management responsibilities, or timing may change the entire direction of the discussion.

    The hypothetical owner’s concern about local decision-making illustrates the point. The useful information was the connection between responsiveness and customer retention. Recognizing that connection changed who the buyer needed to involve and what the next meeting needed to address.

    Keep three judgments separate

    A substantive conversation should improve the team’s understanding of three things.

    Business fit: whether the company appears consistent with the investment thesis.

    Owner interest: whether the owner sees a reason to explore a relationship with this particular buyer.

    Transaction readiness: whether there is a plausible path to taking the discussion further, given the owner’s circumstances and unresolved conditions.

    An attractive business may have an owner who is willing to learn but has no current intention of transacting. A motivated seller may own a company that does not fit. An owner may be seriously interested while needing to resolve a shareholder issue or understand how a partnership would operate.

    These distinctions should survive the call notes and the internal discussion.

    They also prevent a meeting from carrying more meaning than it deserves. An owner can accept a conversation out of curiosity. An NDA can establish permission to exchange information without establishing conviction about a transaction.

    More substantive evidence comes from what the parties are doing and learning. Is the owner asking specific questions about the partnership? Helping resolve uncertainties? Following through on agreed actions? Explaining the conditions under which proceeding would make sense?

    No single action proves intent. Together, those observations support a more informed judgment.

    Recognize the limits of the first conversation

    A cold call cannot establish everything. Some information will be unavailable, sensitive, or better discussed directly with the buyer.

    The standard should be clear understanding of what has been established and why the next conversation is worthwhile.

    An originator may reasonably recommend an introduction with a question still unresolved. Perhaps the buyer’s operator is best placed to assess a technical issue. Perhaps the owner needs to understand the buyer before sharing detailed financial information.

    That judgment should be explicit. The investment team should know what remains open and why the opportunity merits its time.

    The firm also needs to recognize a genuine incompatibility. Persuasive ability is valuable when it helps the parties evaluate a credible partnership. Concealing a mismatch creates avoidable work and weakens trust.

    Judge the introduction and handoff together

    The introduction is one of the clearest places to inspect the quality of the preceding work.

    Consider a short description of the hypothetical commercial services business:

    Approximately $18 million in revenue. Owner is open to a partnership and available next week.

    That may be sufficient to arrange a meeting. It gives the investment team little basis for preparing one.

    A substantive briefing for the same hypothetical company could look like this:

    AreaContext the buyer can use
    Business and fitThe company serves commercial facilities in a region relevant to the platform. The owner describes substantial repeat business; the share under recurring contracts remains unconfirmed.
    Financial informationThe owner estimates $18 million in revenue and approximately $3 million in adjusted EBITDA. Both figures were provided verbally. Financial records and adjustments have not been reviewed.
    Owner’s situationThe owner wants capacity to pursue larger customers while preserving the responsiveness of the local organization. Retirement has not been identified as the objective.
    Buyer proposition discussedThe conversation explored potential support for larger accounts and additional capabilities. The owner wants to understand which resources would be available and how they would be used.
    Concern requiring attentionThe owner believes local operating decisions are important to customer retention and is concerned about centralized dispatch. No commitments about the future operating model have been made.
    Purpose of the next meetingDiscuss the operating relationship with the relevant platform executive and determine whether both parties want to proceed to a more detailed information exchange.

    The additional information changes the buyer’s preparation.

    The investment team knows that financial fit is preliminary, that repeat business still needs to be distinguished from contracted recurrence, and that the owner’s interest is connected to a specific growth objective.

    It also knows what the owner has heard, what has not been promised, and which issue could affect the relationship.

    Those are commercially useful distinctions.

    A longer note is valuable only to the extent that it improves understanding. The buyer should be able to enter the meeting with an informed next question.

    The owner should experience continuity

    The handoff is part of the same standard.

    An owner has formed an impression of the buyer through the person who made contact. If the next meeting starts with questions already answered and a generic restatement of the buyer’s pitch, the conversation can feel as though it has gone backward.

    The investor should know why the owner agreed to meet. The owner should know who is attending and what those people can contribute.

    The originator who established the relationship can provide continuity, clarify relevant context, and help the buyer begin from a more informed position. As the relationship develops, the buyer and owner need room to establish their own working relationship.

    Attendance should follow the purpose of the discussion. In the hypothetical example, the relevant operating executive may contribute more than another participant who can describe the investment thesis but cannot explain the operating model.

    The end of the meeting deserves equal attention. What did the parties learn? What remains unresolved? What did each agree to do? Who owns the follow-up?

    A strong handoff preserves the reason the owner became interested and gives the buyer a practical opportunity to build on it.

    Look for momentum between the visible milestones

    A pipeline records visible events: conversations, meetings, information exchanges, indications of interest, and further transaction steps.

    A great deal of origination value sits between those events.

    An owner asks a question. Someone gets a substantive answer. The answer makes another discussion worthwhile. That discussion resolves an uncertainty and gives both parties enough confidence to proceed.

    Each exchange creates a reason for the next.

    Responsiveness affects that sequence. I have seen a client’s request to contact a company turn into a completed call and useful owner feedback within minutes. The value was immediate: the buyer could make its next decision while the question was still active.

    That example reflects a working habit worth examining. When a priority becomes clear, does it become action? When the firm learns something consequential, does the information reach the buyer promptly? Does someone take responsibility for the next step without repeated prompting?

    A scheduled weekly meeting is useful for reviewing the search. It should not become the only moment when important information moves.

    Tenacity requires an understanding of the situation

    A relationship may require repeated effort over months. The quality of that effort depends on how well the team retains and uses context.

    An owner who becomes difficult to reach may be busy, uncertain, waiting on another person, or losing interest. Repeated attempts alone do not establish which explanation is most likely.

    The originator needs to consider what remains unresolved and what would give renewed contact a purpose. If the owner has asked to reconnect after an operating decision, that preference should inform the work. If the buyer has answered a material question, the answer needs to reach the owner.

    There are also situations in which a transaction process creates friction unrelated to the attractiveness of the partnership.

    An owner may have agreed to share information without understanding the size of the request. A buyer may be waiting for a full package when one narrower question is driving the immediate decision. An owner may need clarity about how sensitive information will be used before becoming comfortable proceeding.

    Where the engagement includes this responsibility, the origination firm should help identify the obstacle and bring it to the appropriate people.

    That can lead to a clearer explanation, a better-sequenced request, or the involvement of someone able to resolve the concern. It can also reveal that the owner is unwilling to take the steps necessary to proceed.

    The response should follow the evidence.

    The buyer has responsibilities too

    An originator can develop interest that the buyer then fails to sustain.

    If an owner follows through and the investment team goes quiet, continued outreach from the origination firm cannot replace the buyer’s participation. The same is true when the buyer arrives unprepared or cannot substantiate something that featured prominently in its positioning.

    A capable firm should be comfortable identifying those problems.

    References can make this behavior visible. Listen to what happens after the first meeting, particularly when progress slows. Who notices? Who identifies the unresolved issue? Who acts? Does the buyer have to keep asking for updates, or does useful information arrive with a recommendation?

    That is a more concrete way to evaluate tenacity than a description of the team as proactive.

    Read the results in light of the work

    Closed transactions matter. Understanding what the origination firm contributed requires more context than a list of announcements.

    Was the owner already seeking a buyer? Did the firm identify a company the client had not considered? Did it reopen a dormant relationship? Did it help an initially uncertain owner understand a possible partnership? Did it remain involved as the opportunity developed?

    Each can be a legitimate contribution. They demonstrate different capabilities.

    The same discipline applies to an engagement that did not produce a closing. Relevant opportunities may have failed later for understandable reasons. The buyer may have changed direction. The market may have proved more constrained than expected. Execution may also have fallen short.

    The absence of a transaction needs an explanation, as does a successful outcome.

    Understand what conversion rates measure

    A conversion rate needs a defined starting population, outcome, and period.

    “Half of our conversations become opportunities” could describe five introductions from ten owner conversations. It leaves unanswered how many companies were researched, how many owners were reached, what qualified as an opportunity, and what happened after the introduction.

    The result may reflect strong execution. It may also reflect selective outreach, a receptive market, or a broad qualification standard.

    The number becomes more useful when the underlying work is visible.

    A firm that develops genuine interest should be able to explain why owners continued and how the opportunities progressed. A firm that researches carefully should be able to show what it learned about fit. A firm that follows through should be able to account for unresolved questions and agreed actions.

    Also distinguish recent opportunities from those that have had time to develop. A new introduction and one that has sat unchanged for months provide different evidence.

    Reporting should improve the next round of work

    The person speaking with owners should participate in the client discussion. Written notes preserve information. Direct access allows the buyer to examine the interpretation, explain its priorities, and decide what should happen next.

    This is an expectation I carried from working inside PE. The discussion needs to influence the work that follows.

    If few owners are being reached, the team should examine contact accuracy, access, and execution. If relevant owners engage but see little reason to continue, positioning and conversation quality deserve attention. If meetings occur but repeatedly stall afterward, the team needs to examine expectations, handoffs, buyer participation, and the substance of the opportunities.

    These are starting points for investigation. The same symptom can have several causes.

    The history should also remain useful when circumstances change. A business passed on because it lacked standalone management may become relevant after the buyer acquires a platform with the necessary leadership. A company recorded simply as “not a fit” gives the next person much less to work with.

    A good search leaves the buyer with a more informed understanding of the market and its relationships, including the reasons behind decisions.

    Meet the people who will do the work

    A compelling pitch establishes that someone at the firm can sell. Your engagement depends on the people who will research, call, interpret, communicate, and follow through after you sign.

    Meet those people and understand how the work is organized.

    Capacity deserves a practical discussion. A mature search with a stable universe differs from a new platform mandate requiring substantial learning and positioning. Several developing owner relationships can demand more attention than a much larger group of unresponsive prospects.

    A mandate count alone does not tell you whether the team can give your assignment the attention it needs.

    The organization behind the individuals matters as well. When I began building a firm, considerable effort went into practices that rarely appear in a pitch: how research was challenged, how owner context was preserved, how changed criteria reached subsequent calls, and how someone could pick up a relationship without losing what had already been learned.

    Those details affect consistency.

    A client should be able to change a criterion and see it reflected in the search. An owner should be able to explain a concern once and have it inform later discussions. A colleague covering an absence should know what was promised.

    The firm should also have a way to develop judgment. How are conversations reviewed? Where does a caller go with a difficult question? How does a lesson from one engagement improve another without importing assumptions that do not apply?

    Put sector experience in context

    I place less weight on an exact-sector precedent than many buyers do.

    Prior work in a sector can provide vocabulary, relationships, and a shorter learning curve. But a completed transaction does not establish that the team assigned to you can perform the next search well.

    There is substantial transferable judgment in origination: learning how a business works, recognizing owner priorities, explaining a buyer credibly, and understanding how a relationship develops.

    A capable team should bring that experience into a new market, arrive with a researched starting view, and improve its understanding through informed conversations with founders and the buyer.

    Some assignments require specialized technical or end-market knowledge. Establish how the team will obtain and apply it. For many others, the more revealing issue is how quickly people learn and whether they recognize the limits of their current understanding.

    A discussion of an initially unfamiliar market can be especially useful. What did the team need to learn? What did owners explain that changed its view? Which assumptions transferred, and which needed to be reconsidered?

    You are evaluating the people’s ability to understand and execute your assignment, alongside the relevance of their previous work.

    Compare the responsibility and the economics

    The term buy-side origination can cover different scopes.

    An introduction service can be valuable to a buyer with the internal capacity to qualify businesses, develop interest, and manage every subsequent step. A lean team executing a demanding acquisition strategy may need an external firm to carry considerably more responsibility.

    Establish that division before comparing fees.

    The division has names in practice. An appointment setter treats the booked meeting as the finished product; what happens afterward belongs to the buyer. A deal catalyzer treats a completed transaction as the objective and works backward from it: concerns surfaced before the introduction, momentum maintained through the quiet stretches, the buyer told when its own response time has become the obstacle. Appointment setting scales with headcount. Catalyzing scales with judgment, and the two should not be priced or evaluated as the same service. A useful test is to ask what the firm did on its last several opportunities after the first meeting was booked.

    Who develops the positioning? What must be established before an introduction? Who prepares the buyer? What involvement continues afterward? When an opportunity stalls, who is expected to understand why and act?

    A premium fee should correspond to work the buyer values and evidence that the firm can perform it well.

    A low cost per introduction may leave considerable qualification and relationship work with the investment team. A higher fee needs to be supported by the quality and scope of the contribution.

    Model the complete economics at your likely transaction sizes and under several outcomes: no acquisition, an acquisition during the engagement, and an acquisition afterward. Include the retainer, success fee, minimums, credits, expenses, payment timing, and definition of transaction value.

    Resolve the practical ambiguities before signing:

    • Existing relationships: How are companies already in your CRM treated when the firm develops a substantive conversation?

    • Overlapping mandates: What does exclusivity cover, and how are conflicts handled as clients’ criteria change?

    • Post-engagement acquisitions: What triggers the tail, how long does it last, and which companies does it cover?

    • Changes in the process: What happens if the buyer pauses, changes scope, or an owner engages a sell-side advisor?

    • Continuity: What research and conversation history does the buyer receive when the engagement ends?

    Also understand whether compensation from another party could affect the assignment.

    The fee structure influences incentives, but does not establish service quality on its own. A success fee creates an economic interest in a closing. A retainer funds ongoing work. Both still require examination of qualification, conflicts, opportunity allocation, and the firm’s willingness to recommend a pass.

    Set expectations for the first phase

    Before work begins, agree on the initial deliverables, responsibilities, and a date for the first substantive review. The working plan should establish how the team will develop the initial market map, align on acquisition criteria, prepare the buyer’s positioning, reconcile existing relationships, and begin owner outreach. It should also identify what the buyer needs to provide and who will make decisions.

    At the review, both sides should be able to examine the coverage achieved, the assumptions tested, the quality of owner engagement, and the issues requiring adjustment. Which parts of the market have been investigated? What are conversations revealing? Is the buyer’s story making sense to relevant owners? What should change in the next phase?

    Set the timing and expectations around the actual mandate, its starting point, and the work required. A universal meeting quota or closing deadline offers little guidance across very different searches. The review should produce an informed decision about whether the work is progressing as intended and what each party needs to do next.

    How I would make the final decision

    Referrals from buyers pursuing comparable acquisition programs are a useful starting point. The closest comparison may be a similar mandate and working relationship rather than the same sector. Relevant transaction announcements can help identify additional firms to investigate.

    For the final evaluation, give candidates a consistent picture of the assignment: the thesis, operating capabilities, acquisition criteria, a business you would pursue, and a plausible look-alike you would decline.

    Then discuss the work with the people who would execute it.

    I would bring an attractive company my team had struggled to engage and explain what we knew. I would listen for what the proposed team needed to understand about the company, the owner, and us.

    A thoughtful discussion should reveal the team’s judgment. Does it recognize uncertainty? Can it explain where the owner might see a reason to engage? Does it identify an unanswered question in the buyer’s proposition? Can it distinguish what can be researched from what requires a conversation?

    Ordinary work should support that discussion. A market map, an introduction briefing, and a client update can show whether the firm’s thinking survives beyond the sales meeting. Anonymized examples are sufficient where confidentiality requires them.

    References then help test the behavior that a presentation cannot demonstrate over time: responsiveness, patience, candor, continuity, and follow-through. I would give substantial weight to a client’s willingness to trust the same people with another assignment, especially when the client can explain what earned that trust.

    By the time you meet an owner, you should understand why the company matters, why the owner is there, what has already been discussed, and what the two of you need to establish next.

    Getting to that point is substantive commercial work. Carrying the relationship forward requires continued judgment.

    You are hiring people to represent an investment thesis in conversations with business owners. Their decisions influence which companies you see, what those owners understand, and whether a credible partnership becomes worth exploring. The evaluation should let you see that judgment at work.

    Written by

    Shivam Shirolawala

    Founder & Managing Partner

    Shivam Shirolawala is the Founder and Managing Partner of Grey Fox Partners.

    LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

    More from Grey Fox